Discussion thread for B. grandiflora. If you would like to add a comment, click the Post Reply button.
Discussion thread for B. grandiflora. If you would like to add a comment, click the Post Reply button.
That looks exactly like Koghensis, right down to the flower.
Hmmmmmmmm,
I checked, and they are both accepted names. Crownal region looks a little different to me. But I am keying only off of Jeff and Geoff.
Living On a Volcano
Kona, The Big Island of Hawaii
Hi all,
koghiensis show many much more leaves. And pretty erected leaves ! brown/orange colored new leaves for koghiensis. Much more bigger fruit for grandiflora. Much more space between grandiflora's leaflets. Don't need to talk about the size of the grandiflora's inflorescence... Grandiflora is pretty rare in the wild and in cultivation.
Mat.
I have a Kogi and you're right, it does look like that. I have never seen a confirmed B. grandiflora or a pic.
I may be going to Jeff's sometime in the next month, or at least meeting with him somewhere. I'll show him the pic and confirm what he knows.
Living On a Volcano
Kona, The Big Island of Hawaii
http://www.palmtalk.org/forum/index....=post&id=30876
According to this pic I'm pretty Sure this palm from Jeff is a grandiflora. Couldn't be dumasii due to inflo/infruct. Couldn't be koghiensis due to crown area and size of existing fruits.
There is something I would like to clarify. I said grandiflora's inflorescence are bigger than koghiensis. That's right but not so much. Most important difference is about flowers themselves. Really bigger on grandiflora. An other thing is that koghiensis inflo/infruct have many much more "stem" than grandiflora.
Those differences (number of "stem" and size of flowers) could be easly seen on those following koghiensis pics. For grandiflora's flower size reference please take the new cal palm book and take a look p67 plate27 picD with Jean-Paul Tivollier.
http://www.palmpedia.net/wiki/images...etiokoginf.jpg
http://www.palmpedia.net/wiki/images...sis_flower.jpg
Saw them in the wild this past weekend. Awesome trip.
Mat.
Here is an updated pic of the same plant in Marcus's garden but with fruit.
![]()
Very interesting pics to compare with koghiensis or dumasii. Many thanks.
Mat.
Thanks for the pic Nick. (Almost wrote picnic)
If you want to upload the Hi-Res version to the wiki, I'll put it on the B. grandiflora page. When uploaded to the forum, pics are automatically downsized.
Living On a Volcano
Kona, The Big Island of Hawaii
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)